Rubric

Find Rubric
Keep in mind that 54 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Literary Analysis Rubric II
Literary Analysis Rubric II
Criteria Ratings Pts
Thesis / Focus
threshold: pts
20 pts
Advanced-Thesis and claims are insightful and create a focus for the essay.
17 pts
Thesis and claims adequately address the prompt and organize the essay.
15 pts
Basic-Thesis and claims partially address the prompt.
13 pts
Below Basic-Thesis superficially address the prompt.
10 pts
Far Below Basic-Thesis doesn't address the prompt.
pts
20 pts
--
Organization / Structure
threshold: pts
20 pts
Advanced-Includes logical progression of ideas that develop the claims.
17 pts
Proficient-Body paragraphs adequately support the thesis and claims.
15 pts
Basic-Body paragraphs partially develop the claim and the progression of ideas is somewhat logical
13 pts
Below Basic-Body paragraphs inadequately develop claims and the progression of ideas is uneven.
10 pts
Far Below Basic-Body paragraphs fail to develop claims with little or no organization of ideas.
pts
20 pts
--
Evidence / Support
threshold: pts
20 pts
Advanced-Provides substantial and well-chosen evidence that is seamlessly woven in to the argument.
17 pts
Proficient-Provides adequate and relevant evidence to support claims with clear lead-ins.
15 pts
Basic-Provides some evidence that is somewhat connected to the claims but lacks adequate lead-ins.
13 pts
Below Basic-Provides minimal or irrelevant evidence to support claims without lead-ins or context.
10 pts
Far Below Basic-Provides irrelevant, little, or no evidence.
pts
20 pts
--
Analysis
threshold: pts
20 pts
Advanced-Shows insightful understanding of text and uses persuasive reasoning to connect evidence to claims.
17 pts
Proficient-Shows competent understanding of topic/text to logically connect evidence with claims.
15 pts
Basic-Shows superficial understanding of topic/text with limited reasoning to connect evidence with claims.
13 pts
Below Basic-Shows limited or flawed understanding of topic/text with simplistic or illogical reasoning.
10 pts
Far Below Basic-Shows no understanding of topic/text. Lacks reasoning.
pts
20 pts
--
Voice / Style
threshold: pts
10 pts
Advanced-Uses varied sentence structure and advanced academic vocabulary.
9 pts
Proficient-Uses correct and varied sentence structure with appropriate academic vocabulary.
7 pts
Basic-Uses mostly correct and some varied sentence structure and academic vocabulary.
6 pts
Below Basic-Uses limited or repetitive sentence structure with little academic or appropriate vocabulary.
5 pts
Far Below Basic-Lacks sentence mastery and fails to use academic vocabulary.
pts
10 pts
--
Mechanics / Proofreading
threshold: pts
10 pts
Advanced-Is nearly error free (grammar, punctuation, spelling, capitalization)
9 pts
Proficient-Contains few minor errors (grammar, punctuation, spelling, capitalization)
7 pts
Basic-Contains some errors which may cause confusion (grammar, punctuation, spelling, capitalization)
6 pts
Below Basic-Contains numerous errors in conventions which cause confusion (grammar, punctuation, spelling, capitalization).
5 pts
Far Below Basic-Contains serious errors that cause confusion (grammar, punctuation, spelling, capitalization)
pts
10 pts
--